Mumbai: The temporary ban on the sale of tobacco products during the ongoing lockdown to curb the spread of COVID-19 is an opportunity to reduce tobacco consumption in India, the world’s second biggest consumer, experts say. Forced to go without tobacco for over six weeks and isolated from social circles where tobacco use is common, users will find it easier to quit.
Nearly 267 million, or 29% Indians aged 15 and above, currently use tobacco in some form, as per the Global Adult Tobacco Survey (GATS): India 2016-17 Report. Up to 199 million tobacco users in India either chew it or apply it on their gums and teeth in various forms; half that number (99 million) smoke, as per available data.
During the ongoing pandemic, a government directive on April 15, 2020, asked for a “strict ban” on the sale of “liquor, gutka, tobacco etc” for health reasons. Two of these reasons are critical, health experts say:
- Since COVID-19 primarily affects lung functioning, patients who are smokers tend to need intensive care and ventilation more than non-smokers, as per the World Health Organization. Fatality rates were higher among patients with comorbidities such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes, hypertension, chronic respiratory disease or cancer, some of which are directly related to smoking. In India, of the 480 deceased on April 18, 83% had comorbidities.
- The use of chewable tobacco leads to increased production of saliva and thus the urge to spit, as an appeal from the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) explained. “Spitting in public places could enhance the spread of the COVID-19 virus,” it said.
“Quitting tobacco use may be especially important at this time to reduce the harm caused by COVID-19,” according to the WHO. Tobacco users who manage to quit would almost immediately have improved lung and cardiovascular functioning and be better placed to manage comorbid conditions if infected, it said.
“This is an ideal opportunity to make people aware of the harmful effects of tobacco consumption as they are scared and listen to you in such moments,” Ravi Mehrotra, chief executive officer of the ICMR’s India Cancer Research Consortium, told IndiaSpend. “With the ban in place, if people can manage 2-3 weeks without it, then why not forever?”
About 55% of smokers and nearly 50% of smokeless tobacco users are interested in quitting the habit or plan to do so, as per the GATS report. For those keen to quit, the lockdown might be a good opportunity, said Mehrotra. “Many times, the use of tobacco products, especially smoking, is a social activity among friends, colleagues and fellow tobacco users,” he pointed out. “Now that people are in isolation because of social distancing, this could be a good opportunity [to kick the habit].”
It is estimated that more than 1.3 million people in India--nearly as many people as the population of Arunachal Pradesh--die of health issues caused by tobacco use every year, the GATS report said. Of them, 1 million deaths can be attributed to smoking and the rest to the use of smokeless tobacco products.
‘Facilitate massive efforts to quit’
“This is the absolute best time to quit smoking,” said Gan Quan, director, tobacco control, at The Union, an advocacy on tuberculosis and lung disease, headquartered in Paris, in a statement on April 6, 2020. “Countries have a moral imperative to advise their citizens of this urgent fact and facilitate massive cessation efforts.”
The level of addiction is high among tobacco users in India: 59% of those who consume it daily do so within 30 minutes of waking up and 78% within the first hour. About one in every 10 adults in India smoke, and 80% (80.1 million) of them smoke every day and 19.4 million occasionally.
The more popular tobacco products in India are smokeless, as we mentioned earlier. Khaini, a tobacco-lime mixture with 104.1 million users and gutka, a tobacco-lime-areca mix with 63.6 million users, are the two most commonly consumed, as per the GATS study. This is followed by betel quid (paan) with tobacco, products for oral application and paan masala--a mixture of tobacco, areca nut, slaked lime, catechu and other flavouring agents.
The use of smokeless products is particularly problematic during the pandemic because it increases the urge to spit, as we said. “Chewing of tobacco leads to spitting which contains bacteria,” explained Pankaj Chaturvedi, professor, department of surgical oncology, head and neck services, at the Tata Memorial Hospital, Mumbai. “Even while doing tests for COVID-19, the swab is collected from the throat which contains the virus in the saliva. So when the infected person spits, the entire virus is loaded into that saliva and the droplets are then thrown in the air. This risks the entire population in the sphere of influence or radius.”
Tobacco causes a loss of nearly Rs 1 lakh crore ($13 billion) every year to the exchequer in terms of healthcare expenditure and is the number one preventable cause of death among youth, said Chaturvedi. The ban on tobacco should be extended beyond the epidemic too, he suggested.
“More awareness and better resolve is required to stop the use of tobacco products over the next two-three weeks because once people realise that they can avoid it and overcome the withdrawal symptoms, they will not let it come back into their life,” he said.
Suppressed immunity among smokers
“A recent study in China showed that the odds of disease progression (including to death) were 14 times higher among people with a history of smoking compared to those who did not smoke,” said Mehrotra. “They are also at risk of developing pneumonia. If you are a smoker it increases the risk of being infected with diseases related to respiratory illnesses like COVID-19 or tuberculosis.”
Smokers are susceptible as fingers (and possibly contaminated cigarettes) come in contact with lips which increases the possibility of transmission of virus from hand to mouth.
#COVID-19: Tobacco use & Vaping:— WHO South-East Asia (@WHOSEARO) April 10, 2020
Smoking & other forms for smoking products can increase your chances of getting COVID-19 by transferring the virus by bringing your hand to your mouth.
Quit now. It's never too late to quit#coronavirus pic.twitter.com/G9E1YJm9qz
“Smoking in many ways predisposes people to coronavirus infection,” Chaturvedi said. “They have higher chances of getting COVID-19 infection because their defence in the respiratory system is low, being susceptible to pathogens, bacteria or any virus. Their immunity is suppressed because the mucosal barrier is damaged because of smoking.”
Half of Indian users want to quit
About 55% of smokers and nearly 50% of smokeless tobacco users, as we said, are interested in quitting or plan to do so, the GATS report revealed.
Nearly two in five (39%) smokers and one-third (33%) smokeless tobacco users tried to quit the use of tobacco products in the past 12 months of the survey conducted, the GATS report said.
“In India, about 2% of the adult population was formerly smoking tobacco every day but has now stopped smoking completely,” the GATS report stated. But the quit ratio for smokeless tobacco use is very low--5.8% of daily smokeless tobacco users successfully quit compared to smokers (16.8%).
Why a tobacco ban can be challenging
While experts welcome a permanent ban on tobacco, they also flag the challenges. “People suffer from addiction and it is important to have infrastructure in place to support those who will get into withdrawal,” Mehrotra said. “There are many medicines, gums etc to help during the withdrawal phase but these are expensive. Counselling by physicians will be the other option but in such a situation that will not be practical, so in that case they will need phone counselling, through Quitline services (1800 227787) of the government.”
A ban on tobacco products will involve multiple ministries, Chaturvedi pointed out. “Banning of tobacco products comes under the purview of the health ministry, but the crop comes under the ministry of agriculture; the sale of cigarette and tobacco products comes under the ministry of commerce while bidi workers come under ministry of labour and gutka manufacturing comes under ministry of MSMEs,” he said. “Hence there is a lot of overlapping when it comes to decision-making and other ministries should be ready to handle the shock [of a ban].”
There are two aspects when it comes to deciding on a ban on tobacco products--demand and supply, Chaturvedi pointed out: “The demand aspect can be brought down by the consumer, understanding the risk in the time of COVID-19. The decision on the supply side is totally political. If people quit, then certainly there will be no demand and as a result supply will stop.”
(Mallapur is a senior analyst with IndiaSpend.)
We welcome feedback. Please write to email@example.com. We reserve the right to edit responses for language and grammar.